Tucker Carlson interview highlights myths that hinder Middle East dialogue

A Feb. 20 interview between Tucker Carlson and U.S. Ambassador Mike Huckabee included claims that questioned the historical legitimacy of Palestinian and some Israeli populations; those remarks drew regional criticism, including condemnations from 15 Middle East governments and a White House clarification.

An interview on Feb. 20 between Tucker Carlson and U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee included statements that questioned the historical legitimacy of both Palestinians and parts of Israel's Jewish population. The exchange drew attention because it echoed broader assertions about origins and peoplehood that feature in regional debates. Media coverage reported criticism across the Middle East, and the White House issued a clarification about the ambassador's remarks. The article argues that these forms of denial make meaningful progress in talks unlikely. Key facts: - The Feb. 20 interview featured Carlson questioning whether many Israeli Jews are of European origin and Huckabee questioning Palestinian peoplehood while using biblical terms such as "Judea" and "Samaria." - Media reports say the remarks prompted condemnation from 15 Middle East governments and led to a White House clarification of the ambassador's comments. - The article states there is no factual basis for denying the historical presence of either Jewish or Palestinian communities in the territory and notes both groups have long histories there. - The author concludes that when negotiators or influential figures deny the other's legitimacy, prospects for negotiated settlement are weakened. Summary: The author contends that public figures expressing mutual denials of existence reinforce entrenched myths and complicate diplomacy. The remarks have prompted regional rebukes and a U.S. clarification. Undetermined at this time.